[Hot Takes from the Noonas] Reversal of fortune for Good Manager and Saimdang: Light's Diary

Advertisement

"Saimdang: Light's Diary" was initially winning the ratings battle against "Good Manager", but slipped behind on Thursday. What went wrong?

"Saimdang: Light's Diary" was highly promoted as the return of popular actor, Lee Young-ae after a 14 year absence from dramas. Hence, it was not surprising to see a 16.3% rating with the drama's first episode.

In contrast, "Good Manager", a workplace comedy starring Namkoong Min, was seen as a scrappy underdog, in spite of the actor's optimistic prediction of 35% ratings. The drama debuted with a modest 7.8% rating.

How quickly things have changed in the past two weeks. As of Thursday's broadcast, "Saimdang: Light's Diary" has fallen to 12.3% ratings, whereas "Good Manager" has had a meteoric rise to 13.8%.

It would appear that "Saimdang: Light's Diary" is losing viewers over a boring plot, dated production values, and the poor acting or complete absence of handsome male lead, Song Seung-heon. Sadly, since "Saimdang: Light's Diary" is entirely pre-produced, the drama will not be able to react to viewer criticism. We can only hope that the PD foresaw the issues and fixed them independently.

Meanwhile, "Good Manager" is winning viewers with its comedy and unique take on work culture. Perhaps, the same viewers who made "Incomplete Life" a cable hit are looking for the outlet that "Good Manager" can provide for their office frustrations.

The failure of "Saimdang: Light's Diary" would be a blow to Lee Young-ae's ego, but not a career destroyer since none of the criticisms have been directed at her. "Good Manager" is exceeding expectations, and may provide the reward vacation that 15 year veteran of dramas, Namkoong Min has dreamed of. So, the real loser in this Wednesday Thursday time slot ratings war is "Missing 9", which started at 6.5% ratings, has sunk to a dismal 4.8%, and has never even ranked.

Love,

JK of Noonas Over Forks